We have more than two options. A critique of reason does not have to be a call for the return of superstition and arbitrary power. Our problems do not lie with reason itself but with our obsessive treatment of reason as an absolute value. Certainly it is one of our qualities, but it functions positively only when balanced and limited by the others.
As an inclusive quality, imagination is thus our primary force for progress, whatever progress is.
Elites quite naturally define as the most important and admired qualities for a citizen those on which they themselves have concentrated.