We nothing know, but what is marvellous; Yet what is marvellous, we can't believe.
Edward Young (1767). “The Works of the Author of the Night-thoughts: In Four [i.e. Five] Volumes”, p.225
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/65fb2/65fb22e01984290028a720df67a3b823193a0d60" alt="We nothing know, but what is marvellous; Yet what is marvellous, we can't believe."
We nothing know, but what is marvellous; Yet what is marvellous, we can't believe.