When a false argument puts on the appearance of a true one, then it is properly called a sophism or fallacy.
Isaac Watts (1813). “The Works of the Rev. Isaac Watts D.D. in Nine Volumes”, p.495
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/297ba/297ba98945b026dadef107933d0d4a4f336586db" alt="When a false argument puts on the appearance of a true one, then it is properly called a sophism or fallacy."
When a false argument puts on the appearance of a true one, then it is properly called a sophism or fallacy.