ThanksGiving is good but ThanksLiving is better.
Matthew Henry (1825). “The Life of the Rev. Philip Henry, A.M.: With Funeral Sermons for Mr. and Mrs. Henry”, p.236
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d4bcb/d4bcb51bc963232c3e2ffe6ab4da0b808cfad740" alt="ThanksGiving is good but ThanksLiving is better."
ThanksGiving is good but ThanksLiving is better.