It is always dishonest for a reviewer to review the author instead of the author's book.
Edward Abbey (2015). “A Voice Crying in the Wilderness”, p.34, RosettaBooks
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f8a5b/f8a5b7cfc415ce36a67f44ab9e35c6c51c49ae17" alt="It is always dishonest for a reviewer to review the author instead of the author's book."
It is always dishonest for a reviewer to review the author instead of the author's book.